Discipline or compliance?

    I recently shared this image on Twitter:

    This was written in my book “The Innovator’s Mindset,” and since then, my thoughts have evolved on the question.  I will get to that in a minute.
    Here is one of the challenges I received on the question:

    I believe all 3 are key to success. Without compliance, there’s no opportunity to develop the disciplined mind for engagement and empowerment. https://t.co/5RPMyHNfXz
    — K Welch (@KWelch7) December 30, 2018

    I agree to some extent with the comment. I don’t believe that these are an “either/or” scenario but empowerment is the end goal, yet compliance and engagement are steps in the process, not a final destination.

    The word I want to focus on here is “discipline.” From what I have read in many comments, “compliance” and “discipline” get used interchangeably where there is a crucial distinction between the words. In my view, compliance is done to you by others. Discipline is something you do to and for yourself.  If you look at through the perspective of sports, compliance is listening to my coach and doing what I am told. Discipline is doing things that make me better when my coach isn’t necessarily asking or watching.  That will separate the good from the great.
    When I think of “discipline,” this Muhammad Ali quote says it well:

    Doing something challenging when you are not asked or pushed by others is not compliance; it is discipline.  Helping our learners develop that internally is crucial if we want “empowerment” to lead to success in the short and long term.


    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *


    You May Also Like

    Cheating or Resourceful?

    As I was watching students build a “cotton ball sling-shot” with items that they ...

    Surface Level can be a Starting Point, but not the End Goal

    I fell upon some articles by Tom Goodwin, who focuses on innovation, but from a ...

    “Deficit Comparisons” To “Abundance Introspection”

    There is so much “grey” here but I am trying to write to understand ...

    Connecting Professional Learning and Leadership

    Years ago I heard about a great program from a school district that wanted ...

    All Toward Supporting Students

    Two quotes that stuck out to me in my reading this weekend. The first ...

    Focused On Who You Serve and Your Why

    Wow…that story opened my eyes. A few reminders from this story about leadership and anyone ...

    Appreciating the “Moment” in Different Ways

    I have seen this picture recently, but I shared an article this morning titled, ...

    Finding a Way

    I love this little video on how the “desk” has changed over the years: ...

    Ask Questions and Listen

    Carol Dweck’s work on “mindsets”, has been one that (justifiably so) educators have gravitated ...